Our Current Political Turmoil -- The Cause and a Cure

Politicial theorist Yuval Levin’s American Covenant is an important and timely book. If you are wondering what is wrong with American politics and our government’s ongoing failure to address and attempt to solve pressing political and societal issues, Levin has your answer—our Congress is failing to fulfill its proper function according to the Constitution. Once that domino falls, so too come the downstream consequences which seriously impact both the executive office (Congress has ceded far too much power to the President—hence the constant stream of executive orders) and the judicial branch of government (the federal courts and the Supreme Court) has far too often become a determinative body in disputes over legislative matters which should be addressed and debated in the Congress, but which are not.

Levin calls our attention to something quite easy to overlook but vital to understand. The Constitution was never designed to secure complete national unity and full agreement of the citizens. The Constitution was intended to give America a political framework from which to work through our inevitable disagreements by forcing elected officials (Congress) to negotiate over legislation and then compromise to get such legislation enacted. As Levin puts it, “a more unified society would not disagree less, but would disagree better” (3.)

Levin’s purpose statement is clear and capably unpacked in subsequent chapters. He writes,

I begin from the premises that the self-evident truths to which our country has been often imperfectly dedicated from the start remain as true as ever; that the Constitution has enabled us to work toward governing ourselves accordingly (and increasingly so in some important respects) and that the hard work involved in its preservation, improvement, and repair is, therefore, worth our best efforts (8-9).

The Constitution provides the framework for a renewal of public life since it is the supreme legal authority of the land, providing our nation with a rule of law. It provides the means by which our government can address pressing problems through enacting legislation, not by moralizing, pontificating, and social media peacocking. Levin laments that as Congress continues to abandon its constitutional responsibilities, the political framework to solve policy disagreements becomes a bipartisan den of “derelictions of responsibility and corruptions of political culture” (28). This is evident in the behavior of the denizens of our Potemkin Congress including both parties.

Levin ends on a simple but hopeful note. “American politics is an endless argument among people who share a history, a geography, a culture, a national character and a broad sense of commitments in common.” The Constitution gives us a way “to keep our balance as a nation, and avoid large mistakes. And it forces us to act together even when we do not think alike” (299-300).

Diehard partisans and political tribalists will not like Levin’s book. Far too many in Congress would rather “own” the other side by composing social media screeds than do the hard work of addressing the nation’s problems through the crafting and implementation of legislation as the Constitution intends. Performative politics is so much easier than composing legislation, debating, and amending it on the floor of Congress, and then getting it passed into law so that it actually serves the public good.

Sadly, those who need to read Levin’s book will not. But those who are genuinely concerned about the state of our national health and inability to conduct the nation’s pressing business will find an explanation for what is wrong, and a clear direction as to how to fix it.

I highly recommend Levin’s American Covenant.

Note: This post originally appeared in my 8/26/2-24 Musings and updated